Translate

Visualizzazione post con etichetta English Edition. Mostra tutti i post
Visualizzazione post con etichetta English Edition. Mostra tutti i post

lunedì 1 giugno 2026

Campi Flegrei Risk: Safety at the 2027 America’s Cup

 

Castel dell'Ovo - Naples (Gulf of Naples)
The President of the National Institute of Geophysics and Volcanology (INGV) was interviewed just a few hours after the magnitude 4.4 seismic event recorded in Campi Flegrei on May 21, 2026, at 5:50 AM, a tremor located offshore at a depth of 3 kilometers.
When asked by the journalist what citizens should do to continue living in this troubled area of Naples with a modicum of peace of mind, Director Prof. Florindo first clarified that people must follow official information coming from Civil Protection and the Vesuvius Observatory: trusting professionals is the first step toward living in an area characterized by seismic and volcanic risk. The President then recalled that two years earlier a Civil Protection drill (Exe Flegrei 2024) was coordinated by his institute to test and verify the emergency system across all its branches, including evacuation, involving roughly 1,500 citizens.
The drills also included setting up the DI.COMA.C (Command and Control Directorate) in the municipality of San Marco Evangelista (Caserta). The exercise went well, the geophysicist specified. Within that same framework, public information sessions were also organized by Civil Protection, though they appear not to have met with particular public attendance.
Continuing the interview, the head of INGV offered reassurance by noting that the Campi Flegrei volcanic field is one of the most closely monitored areas in the world, 24 hours a day, and that should magma move toward the surface, scientists would be able to detect it hours, if not days, in advance. Moreover, monitoring in the area is being upgraded by deploying stations offshore as well, in the submerged section of the caldera, thanks to six million euros allocated by Minister Bernini, head of the Ministry of University and Research.
A recent study has just noted in its premise that caldera volcanoes are characterized by eruptive hazards that, albeit occurring at low frequency, are generally of high magnitude. From a research standpoint, perhaps with a view to prevention, one must acknowledge that in the Phlegraean area it is unfortunately difficult to investigate the crustal thicknesses beneath the volcanic field, where magma has intruded at various levels and in different volumes, interconnecting through dynamics that remain to be fully understood. Understanding the geological processes inherent in the bowels of the Phlegraean caldera is indeed of fundamental importance in attempting to forecast volcanic risk.
Meanwhile, the shallow and deep crustal subsoil of the Campi Flegrei supervolcano appears to be characterized by intrusive magma located just a few kilometers beneath the surface, although the incandescent material seems modest and tentacular, to the point of not being easily distinguishable from its surroundings. In any event, this discreet intrusion of magma creeping into the top few kilometers interacts heavily with the thermal aquifers that are normally abundant and circulating in the semi-superficial part of the caldera. Overheated by magma and by magmatic gases seeping abundantly from depth, these aquifers generate massive amounts of steam, thus keeping local concern high for both phreatic and magmatic eruptions, given that a phreatic blast could serve as a harbinger of far worse trouble.
On the other hand, the physical interactions occurring primarily within the upper few kilometers generate extraordinarily high pressures, because steam expands enormously to an extent that also depends on the temperatures to which the water is subjected. This could mean that pockets of superheated steam, driven by surges of heat rising from depth, and particularly from intermediate magma accumulations located between 8 and 20 kilometers down, may build up pressure until reaching a critical or supercritical state.
Beyond that depth, down to the transition boundary between the crust and the mantle, lies the deep magmatic source. Here, primitive magmas accumulate, feeding the melt column and its storage reservoirs located at various depths. The deeper investigations probe, the harder it becomes to interpret the dynamic and chemical processes characterizing the caldera's subsoil. Thus, the problem of forecasting becomes even more complex, because what likely makes the difference is understanding how magma batches stored at different levels exchange material, as well as their ability to spread laterally into thin sheets (sills) within the subsoil before ascending.
Even though deep magmatic processes are not entirely clear, it is certain that the superheated steam generated by contact between water and magmatic heat, or its associated fluids, produces enormous pressures capable of deforming superficial strata up to the breaking point of the rock layers. At that moment, seismic waves are released, generating earthquakes that are dangerous precisely because they are shallow. Widespread fracturing of the rock strata should theoretically prevent massive accumulations of energy, yet at the same time the extensive fissuring of these very layers facilitates the upward passage of scorching fluids and magma fractions toward the surface. For now, however, the system as a whole is held together by a complex equilibrium that currently holds, yet could rupture suddenly, giving way to a true eruption after nearly 500 years of volcanic quiescence.
In predictive terms, roughly speaking in the absence of scientific certainties, we can say that the probability of generating a false eruptive alarm is 33.3%. There is equally a 33.3% chance of issuing an eruption forecast timely enough for evacuation, but there is also a 33.3% probability of facing a missed eruptive alarm or an alert issued below the minimum time threshold required for the emergency plan to succeed. On the other hand, Prof. Florindo of INGV stated that a forecast could be possible hours or days before the event occurs. From a purely scientific standpoint, "hours" undeniably remains a forecasting success. The fact that such an accurate forecast might fail to cover the evacuation timelines established in emergency plans is, frankly, not a scientific problem but a technical and administrative one, given that engineering and urban planning have other ways to reduce risk, such as mitigating population density by freezing residential construction. Planners can also act on the emergency and evacuation framework itself, improving it through pragmatic assessments rather than cosmetic arithmetic. For example, waiting one's turn to leave by car or shuttle bus is hardly an optimal strategy.
In any case, to sum up, in principle there is a 66.6% probability that the protection of the population will be safeguarded one way or another, inevitably accepting the possibility of a false alarm.
Remaining on the technical side, it must be noted that the drills conducted so far in Campi Flegrei have virtually no practical utility, because simulating the evacuation of roughly 1,500 residents out of 550,000 is incongruous. The figure of 1,500 corresponds to barely 0.27% of the total residents of the Campi Flegrei Red Zone. Moreover, there is already an unavoidable drill gap dictated by the calm demeanor of participants in the absence of real eruptive danger.
To make the futility of the aforementioned drills even clearer, we can use an analogy: testing a fire evacuation plan in a Type-5 school complex (1,200 students) with a 0.27% sample would correspond to moving barely 3 students out of the entire student body. With those numbers at school, at most you could test whether the school bell works...
As for the informational booths, one must bear in mind that the people of Pozzuoli and Naples have long understood that there are no deterministic forecasting certainties, and therefore find it superfluous to keep hearing the same talking points about what is effectively the "geology of maybes." Citizens would become far more engaged if they were involved in operational decisions, and above all they would take greater interest in Civil Protection's outreach if they received concrete answers regarding their post-eruption fate, should an emergency ever materialize. At present, a vague notion circulates that everyone will be relocated to the Campanian hinterland, yet nobody knows exactly where.
Unfortunately, science does not always advance in giant leaps, and today neither our knowledge of volcanic processes nor ultra-sophisticated monitoring instruments allow for a deterministic prediction of an eruptive event. Anyone choosing to live in the Phlegraean territories must therefore grasp that there are no absolute certainties, only probabilities, even though maximum scientific commitment is undoubtedly applied within the limits of current national and international knowledge. Yet some stubbornly insist on continuing to build inside the intra-caldera area, perhaps in a decentralized, camouflaged fashion, justified by necessity and the buzzword of "resilience," but still doggedly within the Phlegraean Red Zone: in places like Licola and its surroundings... Meanwhile, defining the general and restricted bradyseismic zones has fostered the misconception that those are the only truly dangerous areas in Campi Flegrei, also because far too little emphasis has been placed on magmatic eruption, despite the phenomenon being imminent and representing the true Sword of Damocles hanging over these territories.
Map of the Red and Yellow Zones of Campi Flegrei
As for the America’s Cup, with sailing races scheduled to begin on July 10, 2027, in the waters of the Gulf of Naples, logistical and operational bases as well as the village for the 5 competing teams are currently being completed in Bagnoli, right between the two volcanic zones. There is talk of seismic and eruptive risk for the competitors and their respective crews: in principle, overall risk is contained, because the structures housing boats and staff will presumably be built to anti-seismic standards, and if necessary, in the event of a volcanic alert, the sailing teams already possess the best possible means of transport to escape traffic gridlock, a racing yacht, ideally setting course toward Capri... As for the risk to spectators, given that the races are set to take place along the Caracciolo waterfront, those watching the regattas will actually be positioned south of the hilly boundary line of Campi Flegrei, in the Chiaia district, a location that allows for relatively easy evacuation, at least on foot.
                                                                                Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)


martedì 28 aprile 2026

Vesuvius Risk: A Plinian Eruption Has a Generational Impact.

veduta panoramica con al centro il Vesuvio contornato dall'urbanizzazione metropolitana
Naples and Mount Vesuvius

Back in the 1980s, when the issue of the safety of residents living in the Vesuvian plain in the event of an eruption was concretely raised, it was highlighted that there were no remedies capable of offering adequate physical protection to inhabitants against highly lethal phenomena such as terrifying pyroclastic flows. Composed of volcanic gases, water vapor, ash, pumice, and fragments of magma and rock abraded from the volcanic conduit, pyroclastic flows form following the collapse of the eruptive column. After blasting tens of kilometers high into the atmosphere, once its upward thrust is exhausted, the column collapses back down, generating scorching avalanches that race rapidly down the flanks of the volcano, traveling considerable distances with a turbulent and destructive motion.

It was precisely pyroclastic flows that characterized the deadly Plinian eruption that tragically engulfed the towns of Pompeii and Herculaneum in 79 AD. In that eruption, the Volcanic Explosivity Index (VEI 5) was catastrophic, forming an eruptive column exceeding thirty kilometers in height before collapsing onto itself and generating multiple waves of pyroclastic flows at different intervals that surged downslope, striking towns located at the base of the volcano. Herculaneum was among the first to be hit and destroyed, with flow temperatures exceeding 400 °C and speeds of over 100 km/h.
The scorching clouds that struck Herculaneum were particularly lethal; when they overwhelmed the residents who delayed evacuating by taking shelter along the shoreline inside boat chambers, they brought instantaneous death. On several human remains, in fact, one can observe the "bursting" of the skull caused by the sudden boiling and vaporization of bodily fluids, as well as limbs fractured by thermal shock and reddish bones stained by the thermal decomposition of hemoglobin in the blood...
The boat chambers (fornici) where roughly 350 residents of Herculaneum took shelter to escape the fury of Vesuvius in 79 AD, only to be overwhelmed by pyroclastic flows that vaporized their bodily fluids, causing instantaneous death.

In a broader discussion on habitability in the Vesuvian area, one must keep firmly in mind that it is impossible to predict with guaranteed useful advance notice either the onset of an eruption or the magnitude that will characterize it—a power measured by a numerical index (VEI) that can generally be quantified with reasonable accuracy only after the eruption has ended.
Faced with these two major uncertainties, the level of risk looming over Vesuvian populations is inevitably far from minimal. Every narrative about the heroic resilience of exposed communities is actually built upon the lack of sensory perception of danger and the belief that an eruption can certainly be predicted at least 72 hours in advance, as government information campaigns have long claimed—even though today those tones of predictive certainty have grown rather timid, shifting responsibility onto the Event Tree: a software tool designed to rapidly analyze volcanic monitoring data.
Eighty-two years have passed since the last eruption of Vesuvius (1944), meaning we are approaching a full century of quiescence. A century-long or multi-century quiescence of Vesuvius would not disproportionately worsen the risk factors already inherent inside the current Red Zone, yet it would certainly affect the extent of the hazard area, which could quadruple to encompass zones currently considered safe. Scientific literature indeed states that the Volcanic Explosivity Index tends to rise as periods of geological repose lengthen.
Scientists of the Major Risks Commission (Commissione Grandi Rischi), also drawing on the report produced by a dedicated working group (2012), confirmed that the maximum expected reference eruption for drafting emergency plans at Vesuvius should be a sub-Plinian VEI 4 event. Consequently, the Red Zone was delineated taking into account the work of researcher Lucia Gurioli, who verified in the field and plotted on a map (the Black Line) the maximum runout points of the pyroclastic flows formed during the last sub-Plinian eruption of 1631.
Map of Mount Vesuvius and surrounding territory. The Gurioli Black Line clearly marks where pyroclastic flows stopped during past sub-Plinian eruptions—a deposit limit. Vesuvius Red Zone and Gurioli Line.

Not everyone knows this curved demarcation line, and almost everyone misinterprets it as a safety boundary; in reality, it is merely a deposit limit that fails to account for the advance of the lighter, dilute gaseous surges of a pyroclastic cloud. Moreover, it must be clear that photocopy eruptions do not exist, and the energy released by a volcano can also be represented by decimal figures: for example, VEI 4.2. Such a value corresponds to an energy release twice as great as a VEI 4.0 eruption; an example of intermediate explosivity is offered by the powerful Pollena eruption of 472 AD, whose eruptive style cannot be boxed into a round number and sits between VEI 4 and VEI 5—occurring 393 years after the catastrophic Pompeii eruption of 79 AD.
Should a VEI 4 eruption occur, pyroclastic flows could reach areas located roughly 7–10 km from the crater. Conversely, if the eruption were to reach VEI 5 (Plinian) energy levels—ten times stronger than the benchmark VEI 4 event—pyroclastic flows could travel 15 to 20 kilometers from the eruptive vent. This projection highlights that, with current criteria, disaster prevention faces critical flaws that should at least be disclosed to the public, especially if immediate or medium-term protective measures cannot be guaranteed.
In the event of a volcanic alert, the area subject to preventive evacuation is effectively the VEI 4 zone—the red circle shown in the diagram below, covering roughly 200 square kilometers. By contrast, the concentric ring colored in green to distinguish it clearly indicates an area of approximately 800 square kilometers that could be overrun by pyroclastic flows during a Plinian eruption (VEI 5). This eruptive style carries the concrete probability that scorching clouds will breach the VEI 4 perimeter and push outward to distances of 15–20 kilometers...
Diagram illustrating the difference between the sub-Plinian Red Zone (VEI 4, which also covers VEI 3 eruptions) and the Plinian Green Zone (VEI 5, indicating territories exposed to pyroclastic flows in a VEI 5 eruption), highlighting the need for a regulated zone to prevent uncontrolled urbanization.

In short, a Plinian eruption would engulf a total territory of over 1,000 square kilometers inhabited by several million people. Yet a Plinian eruption has been completely excluded from plausible scenarios... To be even clearer, there is no evacuation plan or directive covering the VEI 5 Green Zone. Thus, residents living within this belt would remain stationary during an alert, watching nature’s extraordinary spectacle without even realizing that their lives are entrusted to statistical calculations that shift over time—even within a matter of hours—and not in a linear fashion.
Within volcanic risk philosophies characterized by multiple factors of indeterminacy, the decision to disregard a Plinian eruption is inevitably indefensible from an ethical standpoint and remains a gamble. The fundamental right to safety dictates that where protection is absent or impossible, there must at least be accurate, timely public information—which is currently lacking. Authorities should state clearly: "Dear citizens, there is no evacuation plan for a Plinian eruption, which remains statistically unlikely. Nevertheless, it cannot be ruled out deterministically because, according to experts, the statistical probability of a Plinian event materializing at Vesuvius ranges from 1% to 11%, depending on the time-window table adopted, both of which are based on different quiescence periods of the volcano. The reference table selected by the Major Risks Commission is Table B."
Statistical tables showing eruptive style probabilities. Tables A and B of eruptive probabilities.

The Major Risks Commission assumed the responsibility of adopting a low-to-medium reference eruption (VEI 4), just as the Vesuvius Observatory and the Civil Protection Department assumed the burden of forecasting by declaring that magma movements are constantly monitored and therefore an eruption cannot catch us by surprise... Finally, let us remember that it will always be the Presidency of the Council of Ministers, after consulting the Major Risks Commission and the Civil Protection Operational Committee, that issues the evacuation order for the Vesuvius Red Zone when necessary.
For departmental and regional experts, 72 hours—corresponding to three days' advance notice before the eruption—are deemed sufficient to evacuate the 700,000 inhabitants of the Red Zone. Objectively, such a number of residents is not easily manageable, given that it exceeds the population of a major city like Palermo. Even from a population density standpoint, several Vesuvian municipalities—especially along the coast—record staggering figures, such as the town of Portici with roughly 11,350 inhabitants per square kilometer: a level of crowding that certainly does not help...
Evacuation procedures stipulate that the 700,000 Vesuvian residents be relocated, in the event of a volcanic alert, across all Italian regions and provinces, islands included. Rapid evacuation modes include ships, trains, buses, and private cars. It must be remembered that to board ships and trains, evacuees must first reach ports and railway stations via collective transport (buses).
Chart illustrating twinning arrangements between Vesuvian municipalities and Italian regions.
Twinning scheme.

Another unknown in analyzing this volcanic territory concerns the aftermath of the eruption—a phenomenon that can last from a few days to several weeks. Once the acute explosive phase has passed, it cannot be ruled out that the 700,000 evacuees will one way or another seek to return to their homes to assess the damage suffered and understand how the State intends to compensate those who sustained severe losses or lost everything—illegal builders included (Ischia docet).
In any case, even if the eruption were to subside within a few days, ruins would scar the Vesuvian landscape, prompting belated reflections on the mistakes made in land management and on the prevention policies implemented—and above all not implemented—to prevent a natural event from turning into a volcanic catastrophe. According to common sense, the next eruption of Vesuvius will empirically redraw the new Red Zone. Buildings swept away by pyroclastic flows or lava flows will most likely not be rebuilt and will delineate the new Red Zone, just as disputes over property boundary lines are guaranteed to arise. Only an eruption similar to the 1944 event (VEI 3) would allow moderate optimism regarding the economic and social recovery timelines of the Vesuvian area—and even then, not immediately.
Among recent initiatives, the Municipality of Pompei has signed onto the memorandum of understanding promoted by the Convivenza Vesuvio Foundation—a project aiming to evacuate Vesuvian residents to municipalities in the Apennine and pre-Apennine belt of Irpinia should the volcano show signs of renewed eruptive activity. The underlying principle is irrefutable, as it would prevent displaced citizens from scattering across distant Italian regions, keeping them within Campania. However, from what little is known, the project seems to contain more statements of principle than concrete operational procedures. Given the vital importance of these issues for citizens, clear answers and guarantees are required.
Indeed, since the early 1950s, the Apennine and pre-Apennine areas have experienced steady depopulation driven by a mix of declining birth rates, lack of jobs, and scarce services and infrastructure, triggering long-term emigration toward coastal provinces, northern Italy, or abroad—especially among young people reluctant to accept limited opportunities for education, leisure, and employment. The housing stock needed for the Convivenza project is not located in major urban centers, but in small towns scattered across the provinces of Avellino and Benevento. The Convivenza Vesuvio initiative could harbor seeds of failure, because Vesuvian residents might accept a "brick-and-mortar tent" temporarily, without ever viewing it as a permanent home worthy of personal investment; their thoughts will always turn back to their historic hometowns...
Finally, we wish to conclude by highlighting two points we consider crucial: the first concerns the green belt labeled VEI 5 in our earlier diagram. That drawing highlights in a color usually associated with normality a territory that is anything but normal—an area that pyroclastic flows can overrun during a Plinian eruption, yet which is omitted from any emergency or evacuation plan. Nonetheless, this zone—which sooner or later will inevitably demand attention—is not governed by any national or regional law, regulation, circular, or recommendation acknowledging its Plinian hazard status. Yet the precautionary principle, even amidst scientific uncertainty, demands prioritizing long-term prevention to safeguard future generations who bear no blame for the territorial layout they inherit. The Green Zone should probably already be designated today as a Yellow Zone (attention) or a Regulated Zone (zona regolamentata), preventing the rise of high-density residential complexes with tall buildings.
Meanwhile, the Plinian VEI 5 area is undergoing relentless urbanization and human settlement, partly because it is called upon to absorb the housing demand displaced from the classic Red Zone, where a total ban on new residential building applies (Regional Law 21/2003). This means that when experts eventually bring the Plinian risk back onto the table—whether due to elapsed geological time, a renewed culture of prevention, groundbreaking scientific discoveries, or updated statistical models—we will be confronted with chaotically overbuilt land offering virtually no margin for structural adaptation along the lines of passive defense, wide roadways, low-rise buildings, and above all open spaces: vast open spaces without which no Civil Protection policy can ever function...
The President of the Campania Region, together with the Civil Protection Department, should bring together scientific and urban planning experts to evaluate the consequences of a VEI 5 eruption in accordance with the precautionary principle and Generational Impact Assessment (GIA) (Valutazione di Impatto Generazionale - VIG). Within the VEI 5 belt, a Regulated Zone status must be enacted so that land governance incorporates strategic planning and management requirements with an eye toward future generations.
The President of the Campania Region should also thoroughly verify the feasibility assumptions underlying the Convivenza Vesuvio Foundation’s project, because expectations of remaining within Campania during a volcanic emergency cannot be raised unless every aspect—from administrative and economic frameworks to the actual census of available housing—has been rigorously verified.
                                                                Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)



mercoledì 21 gennaio 2026

Eruptive Risk at Campi Flegrei: America First!

 

Nisida - Bagnoli: headquarters of the Allied Maritime Command Naples until 2013.

Some time ago, local Neapolitan newspapers reported that personnel at the US Navy base stationed in Naples were issued operational instructions on how to protect themselves from earthquakes or take shelter in the event of a possible volcanic eruption. This major US Navy logistical facility is located at Naples Capodichino (Airport), sitting in relative proximity to both the Mount Vesuvius and Campi Flegrei volcanic districts. These two fiery geographical sectors lie to the east and west of the city of Naples, respectively, and are characterized by a frequently explosive eruptive nature.

The handbook distributed to civilian staff and military families contains provisions from Naval Support Activity (NSA) Naples, stipulating, it seems, that in the event of an eruptive alert, the instructions, orders, and evacuation procedures issued by NSA Naples must take priority over other existing plans... America first!

                                   

The memorandum specifically brings Mount Vesuvius—and above all Campi Flegrei—into focus, as one cannot rule out a seismic resurgence inside the caldera acting as a precursor to an eruption, or at least the continuation of this unpredictable, ongoing geo-bradyseismic unrest capable of generating earthquakes. Knowing how to handle an earthquake is vital. Italy is a geologically young and restless land that must periodically contend with Apennine tectonics, as well as localized volcanic tectonics like that of Campi Flegrei, whose subsoil is characterized by the presence of magma and fluids in a supercritical state of temperature and pressure...

From a seismic emergency perspective, defending against crustal shaking means first and foremost acting on prevention by prioritizing all initiatives capable of structurally retrofitting the buildings where people live and work—military bases included.

Intervention plans for the bradyseismic zone and the restricted bradyseismic zone of Pozzuoli call for rapid structural inspections after every significant earthquake and, where necessary, inspecting engineers can order the evacuation of families from unsafe buildings, relocating them to hotels or facilities designated for this purpose outside the Red Zone.

Campi Flegrei: bradyseismic zones.

The area potentially swept by hazardous volcanic phenomena such as pyroclastic flows should presumably be circumscribed within a circle with a radius of about 10 kilometers from the presumed eruptive vent, covering a total circular area of 314 square kilometers.

These guidelines, however, hold validity only if we rely on the axiom that a potential eruptive event will be characterized by a low or medium Volcanic Explosivity Index—that is, not exceeding VEI 4, corresponding to a sub-Plinian style event. This eruptive style—considered the maximum plausible event pending any different assessment by the Major Risks Commission (Commissione Grandi Rischi)—is the benchmark adopted in emergency plans for both Neapolitan volcanic districts to delimit the boundaries of the two Red Zones to be evacuated if necessary.

If, on the other hand, the eruption were to manifest as a Plinian event—or in any case with a VEI 5 index, ten times larger than a VEI 4—it would pose a massive problem, as the eruption would generate a far wider Red Zone than the one adopted in current emergency plans, with violent phenomena capable of striking segments of the population not covered by preventive evacuation measures.

The opposite is also true: scientists estimate that, in the event of an eruption, the most probable outcome is a modest-scale event of the ultra-Strombolian type (VEI 3), similar to the one that characterized the birth of Monte Nuovo in Pozzuoli in 1538. Unfortunately, the Volcanic Explosivity Index (VEI) is a metric determined post-event, just as the timing of an eruption remains strictly probabilistic.

Outside the Red Zone, during a volcanic emergency, the situation for evacuees should be less dangerous provided they take care to avoid the downwind sector relative to the eruptive vent, where ash and lapilli fallout would be heavy, creating severe disruption and danger from the very first moments of the eruption. In other words, within the first 10 km from the eruptive center, one must as a rule evacuate preemptively to survive. Beyond those kilometers—and especially toward the east—one would face severe hardship, proportional to a person's position and distance from the crater.

Indeed, statistics based on observing prevailing wind directions across the two volcanic areas point to the eastern sectors as those most likely exposed to ash and lapilli fallout, which is why they are pre-classified in emergency plans as the Yellow Zone. During an eruption, pyroclastic products would be blasted high into the air by explosions and then carried by high-altitude winds until gravity pulls them down, forming deposits on rooftops and the ground, starting with the heaviest fragments. While for Vesuvius it is already possible to map the area that would bear the brunt of pyroclastic fallout, for Campi Flegrei this remains uncertain because the exact location of the eruptive vent—which might not even be single—is unknown.

Campi Flegrei: Red and Yellow Zones


Those who unwittingly find themselves beneath the ash cloud (Yellow Zone) would face breathing difficulties, eye irritation, stalled vehicle engines, and disorientation—without finding safe shelter inside buildings with flat roofs, since the accumulation of pyroclastic deposits could trigger dangerous, catastrophic roof collapses with a domino effect starting from the top floor. Finer ash particles, meanwhile, can drift through the atmosphere for hundreds or even thousands of kilometers.

In a volcanic emergency, one must carefully select essential survival supplies to take along. These will vary in type and quantity according to personal needs and, above all, the load capacity of one's vehicle—which should not be a truck, as heavy vehicles can obstruct traffic amidst frightened and impatient motorists. Ultimately, evacuating on foot cannot be ruled out either: a far from remote option should total gridlock occur. In any case, covering a distance of roughly 10 kilometers would require a march of nearly 3 hours, ideally moving in the opposite direction or perpendicular to the prevailing wind.

The US Sixth Fleet contingent in Campania appears to be stationed across Naples Capodichino, Giugliano (Lago Patria), and Gricignano d'Aversa. US Navy military personnel—and especially civilian staff—should in principle comply with the directives issued by the host country and respect the emergency and evacuation plan designed to safeguard the territory. Likely, since the American community would need to be repatriated to the United States in the event of an evacuation, they may have an autonomous organization to reach other US bases outside the volcanic risk perimeter in case of danger; the hope is that their movements will not conflict with the evacuation routes established by Italian Civil Protection.

Moreover, if US military personnel also had to relocate classified documents and electronic communications gear, it cannot be ruled out that they might operate differently from general emergency rules. As things stand, however, simply adopting pitched roofs could increase the resilience of troops inside the military facilities at Capodichino, with an evacuation order directed if necessary solely to non-combatants (NEO) and civilian personnel, as military staff might follow different protocols involving higher operational resilience. Obviously, during an eruption, flight operations at Capodichino Airport would be completely compromised and radio transmissions disrupted.

Traveling by car would allow taking along slightly bulkier items, though care must be taken not to compromise interior cabin space, which serves as the primary living shelter. In an eruption, the top priority is saving human lives, not possessions.

If conditions force an evacuation on foot, it will be wise to pack only water, cash, valuables, essential banking cards, and personal IDs into a backpack—alongside life-saving medications, a flashlight, and mobile phones (ideally with a spare power bank) to receive messages from Civil Protection (IT-Alert) and relatives. The most forward-thinking individuals will likely also bring FFP2 masks and protective goggles...

Generally speaking, provided the Volcanic Explosivity Index forecasts are respected, the American bases should not face exceptional hazards, as they actually lie outside the Red Zones and inside the Yellow Zones, where structural defenses are viable.

Within this context of armed forces exposed to volcanic hazard, it would be interesting to know the emergency plan prepared by the Italian Air Force Academy in Pozzuoli, which sits atop a 155-meter-high lava dome called Monte Olibano. Adjacent to the Solfatara volcano, this site—unlike the American base—is exposed to all volcanic phenomena regardless of the eruptive style. Presumably, the evacuation of the Academy would have to take place during the pre-alert phase, as there would be no sense in exposing cadets to the risks of a general alert phase. Relocating the Academy to facilities adjacent to Grazzanise Air Base might perhaps be a wise preventive decision.

                                                                            Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)




domenica 21 dicembre 2014

The Marsili Submarine Volcano: Offshore Geothermal Energy, Deep Drilling, and Tsunami Risk.

 

Mount Marsili is a colossal volcanic seamount resting on the southern Tyrrhenian seabed, at a depth of several thousand meters and roughly 45 nautical miles northwest of the Aeolian Islands. The ridge of the volcano rises sharply toward the surface, yet remains submerged at a depth of approximately 500 meters below sea level. It would have taken very little for it to emerge above the waves like its Aeolian siblings... Marsili is the largest volcano in the Mediterranean and in all of Europe. Until not long ago, it was considered extinct, but recent core sampling has identified eruptive products dating back less than 5,000 years.

The seismicity recorded across this Tyrrhenian sector and the release of magmatic gases, combined with the well-preserved morphology of several summit volcanic cones, indicate that Marsili is still active, even though its precise hazard level remains unclear... Further deep-sea surveys will very likely be needed to better understand its intrinsic vitality, though we doubt definitive certainties will ever emerge, considering that even for subaerial volcanoes like Mount Vesuvius it is impossible to make bold predictions regarding an eruption, which remains a geological unknown to this day...

The data collected so far on this massive submerged edifice suggest past eruptive activity that was predominantly effusive and perhaps moderately explosive. It is therefore particularly important to continue exploratory campaigns across the Tyrrhenian seabed in order to gather additional geochemical and geophysical data capable of clarifying not only the current state of Marsili, but also that of the other lesser-known volcanoes dotting the surrounding abyssal plain across a wide radius.

Hot fluids, with temperatures ranging between 300 °C and 500 °C, circulating under high pressure like lifeblood through the middle and upper sections of Marsili and even feeding hydrothermal vents, have captured the attention of Eurobuilding S.p.A., which aims to harness these superheated aquifers to generate electricity via one or more floating power plants positioned directly above the volcano. It is certainly an original and futuristic project that will have to overcome serious concerns regarding environmental impact.

A preliminary study, either currently underway or slated for implementation (very little news leaks out), aims first and foremost to establish baseline geophysical and geochemical parameters for Marsili, the surrounding waters, and the overlying surface air prior to drilling. All of these measurements will provide reference data for future comparisons regarding the environmental safeguards that geothermal operations as a whole could undermine. In its introductory notes, Eurobuilding clarifies that the area targeted for drilling and geothermal exploitation is not subject to specific biological, archaeological, or fish-restocking protection constraints, and that the nearest coastline is represented by the Aeolian Islands, located roughly 80 kilometers from the vessel that will drill the exploratory borehole.

The initial screening methods were deemed non-invasive and free of side effects on the environment, to the extent that the Ministry of the Environment and Protection of Land and Sea itself decided not to enforce Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) regulations, at least during this initial phase.

Eurobuilding’s project contains undeniably futuristic and fascinating elements. Generating energy directly above a gigantic submerged volcano requires cutting-edge technology and strong entrepreneurial drive. Naturally, the costs are high, as are the unknowns, far greater than those of an equivalent onshore facility. Hot hydrothermal fluids, contrary to popular belief, are not entirely harmless, as they typically contain highly toxic substances such as arsenic and heavy metals, which certainly are no panacea for health. Capturing these waters therefore requires extreme care. In an open-loop system, pumping the extracted waters, once cooled through geothermal energy conversion, condensed, and reinjected directly into the source reservoir, should largely ensure the containment of pollutants.

In the preliminary screening study, extensive attention was devoted to characterizing water and seabed samples around the drilling site. Considerable space was also dedicated to underwater noise pollution that could damage the sensory organs of cetaceans, alongside setting a threshold limit for the potential surface release of hydrogen sulfide. What is missing, however, is a thorough examination of the hazards directly tied to drilling into an active volcano. From this perspective, the issue is hardly new, having already sparked heated debate over another well-known drilling operation: that of the Phlegraean supervolcano under the Campi Flegrei Deep Drilling Project (CFDDP). That scientific initiative was widely viewed as a gamble. In that case, the rotary drill bit halted at a depth of 500 meters, with a standstill that has lasted for two years with no sign of resuming excavation.

A strong suspicion therefore arises that deepwater drilling enjoys a fast track precisely because of its offshore location. Where there is no local population on site, there is seemingly no risk, yet only seemingly. Should drilling operations directly or indirectly trigger even a remote submarine landslide, the resulting tsunami waves would strike the coastlines, not the drilling rig. Meanwhile, any discharge of hydrothermal pollutants into the sea would produce severe ecological damage depending on the volumes and concentrations dispersed...

Eurobuilding’s scientific committee includes researchers from INGV who could certainly provide stronger arguments regarding the harmlessness of drilling, or, conversely, the risks it may pose to the structural equilibrium of a volcanic edifice characterized by steep, unstable flanks of varying cohesion, stratified layers, and internal dynamism. These arguments should have enriched the preliminary environmental study for the offshore exploratory well named Marsili 1.

Ultimately, drilling into the Marsili volcano offers an opportunity for a broader reflection that must take place sooner rather than later on deep drilling in general, regardless of whether it targets oil, gas, or superheated fluids. Scientific studies on the subject remain deeply controversial today... How should we frame this practice, so unpopular among communities demanding a ban on offshore rigs (southern Sicily is set to be overrun by them), as an additional opportunity for development, or as a reckless gamble?

We have tried knocking on various institutional and political doors to raise the issue and obtain answers, yet without any success. If the decision to drill into Marsili is considered non-negotiable because it is deemed a vital national strategic asset, we ask that these aspects be clarified far more transparently so that exposure to risk is consciously accepted by citizens, granting them genuine freedom of choice regarding foreign energy dependence. After all, a national referendum was held for nuclear power... As can be seen, this is an issue of profound political and scientific significance, one that we hope remains completely immune to the systemic corruption scandals recently uncovered in Italy.

                                                                   Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)

martedì 8 ottobre 2013

The Palinuro Submarine Volcano: Tsunami Risk, Bathymetry, and Interview with Prof. Girolamo Milano (INGV).

 

Glimpse of Cape Palinuro (Cilento coast)

The Palinuro Volcano: Key Information in Brief

-  Current Status: Considered a potentially active or quiescent volcano, characterized by hydrothermal activity and micro-seismicity.

-     Last Eruption: There are no exact historical dates for the last explosive eruption. Data indicate that the cones in the central-eastern sector have crater rims not occluded by sediments, suggesting geologically recent activity.

-  Depth: The summit of the submarine volcano rises to just 84 meters below sea level.

-  Distance from the Coast: Located approximately 100 kilometers off the Cilento coast (Salerno, Italy).

Mount Palinuro is submerged in the Tyrrhenian depths roughly one hundred kilometers off the Cilento coast (Salerno), rising high enough to be reached by an experienced scuba diver or an eighty-meter fishing line. Almost all vessels sailing toward the Aeolian Islands or Sicily pass over or near this mysterious underwater mountain without a tremor from passengers, most of whom are unaware that a considerable number of eruptive vents lie on that seabed.

At the end of October 2013, an international Civil Protection exercise co-funded by the European Union (TWIST, Tidal Wave in Southern Tyrrhenian Sea) took place in Salerno and its province. The operational scenario simulated a tsunami wave generated by a submarine landslide detaching from the flanks of the Palinuro volcano. The Civil Protection Department selected this edifice among those lying in the Tyrrhenian depths because it is the closest to the mainland coast. However, it may not pose the highest landslide hazard, considering that in this regard, according to authoritative scientists, Mount Marsili holds the record. Indeed, in modern oceanographic studies this abyssal giant has been singled out as a potential threat to the Mediterranean due to its steep, unstable, and poised rocky flanks, capable of triggering devastating tsunamis.

Certainly, the history of tsunamis in the Mediterranean is not particularly crowded with events. Nevertheless, several major and even catastrophic phenomena have occurred, such as the tsunami formed following the eruption and caldera collapse of the island of Santorini roughly 3,600 years ago. Notably, around that very same period, the terrible and immensely powerful eruption of Mount Vesuvius known as the Avellino Plinian eruption also took place. Other tsunamis were triggered by the Crete earthquake of July 21, 365 AD. On that occasion, nine-meter-high waves battered the Greek and Libyan coastlines as well as the city of Alexandria in Egypt, where the historian Ammianus Marcellinus recorded the event. The Italian coastline facing Crete was also struck by tsunami waves, which took just over an hour to crash onto the eastern shores of Sicily and Ionian Calabria.

In 1908, the upheavals of the Messina earthquake generated destructive tsunami waves that slammed into the Calabrian and Sicilian coasts, causing considerable damage. In December 2002, an anomalous wave was triggered by a landslide detaching from the subaerial and submarine flanks of Stromboli, causing limited damage that was perhaps somewhat magnified by media coverage.

Prof. Girolamo Milano, geophysicist at the Vesuvius Observatory (INGV), participated in two oceanographic campaigns in 2007 and 2010 that shed new light on the Palinuro volcano, which served as the centerpiece of the TWIST exercise.

Regarding the volcano named after Aeneas's helmsman who perished amidst those waves, Prof. Milano kindly shared insightful details during our interview that lift the veil on these submerged mountain edifices: "Palinuro is located between the Marsili basin to the south, the Apennine chain to the east, and the sedimentary basin of the Gulf of Salerno to the north. The latter is the only area of the southeastern Tyrrhenian Sea unaffected by volcanism. The genesis of Palinuro is still not entirely clear when compared to that of the nearby and better-known Marsili volcano. However, it is hypothesized that the volcanic complex developed along a deep east-west trending structure whose kinematics are compatible with a strike-slip fault."

Professor, since when and what do we know about this submarine volcano?

"The first oceanographic campaigns were carried out in the 1970s. The most recent high-resolution digital terrain model of the seabed, obtained from data acquired in 2007, shows that Palinuro rises from a depth of 3,000 meters up to 84 meters below mean sea level. Its shape approximates an ellipse reaching a maximum length of 55 km in an east-west direction. The summit portion of the volcanic complex consists of superimposed edifices with typical conical and truncated-cone shapes, alongside wide depressions attributable to gravitational collapses. The southern flank is characterized by fairly steep slopes, whereas the northern flank displays gentler walls.

The central sector is the shallowest part of the volcanic complex. Bathymorphological data clearly highlight Palinuro's two most significant volcanic cones. The flat, circular summits of these cones, with diameters of approximately 750 and 2,500 meters, lie at depths of 175 and 84 meters below mean sea level.

Along the eastern margin, additional volcanic cones are clearly visible. The most significant of these is located at a depth of about 570 meters and features a crater roughly 70 meters deep. Its well-pronounced crater rim, unoccluded by sediments, suggests more recent volcanic activity."

Professor Milano, what information have the sediment samples collected on Palinuro provided?

"Currently available mineralogical and petrographic data suggest that Palinuro formed (over 300,000 years ago) across a prolonged time span, and the morphostructural differences between the western, central, and eastern zones likely mark distinct evolutionary stages of the volcanic complex. The western sector appears to be the oldest. Conversely, the presence of numerous cones in the central sector, a volcanic crater with a pronounced rim, greater magnetic anomaly amplitudes detected in this area, and the age of products sampled at the summit strongly suggest that the central sector is the youngest."

Is the Palinuro volcano still active?

"The presence of micro-seismicity with volcano-tectonic characteristics located southeast of the volcanic complex, magnetic anomalies, and hydrothermal activity in the central-eastern sector suggest that the southeastern area could be active. Acquiring new geophysical, petrological, and geochemical data will provide fresh insights, both to better understand Palinuro's genesis within the geodynamic framework of the southeastern Tyrrhenian Sea and to determine whether the volcanic complex, or part of it, should be considered active or quiescent."

Our warmest thanks go to Prof. Girolamo Milano on behalf of our readers and the editorial staff for his valuable scientific contribution.

Schematic map of the southeastern Tyrrhenian Sea showing the location of the Palinuro volcanic complex and a 3D representation (viewed from the south) of the Palinuro Seamount derived from Multibeam bathymetric data acquired during the 2007 oceanographic campaign (figure adapted from the scientific publication: S. Passaro, G. Milano, C. D'Isanto, S. Ruggieri, R. Tonielli, P. P. Bruno, E. Marsella, 2010: DTM-Based morphometry of the Palinuro seamount (Eastern Tyrrhenian Sea): Geomorphological and volcanological implications. Geomorphology, Vol. 115, issue 1-2, 129-140).

                                                                               Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)