Translate

Visualizzazione post con etichetta Volcanic Risk. Mostra tutti i post
Visualizzazione post con etichetta Volcanic Risk. Mostra tutti i post

lunedì 1 giugno 2026

Campi Flegrei Risk: Safety at the 2027 America’s Cup

 

Castel dell'Ovo - Naples (Gulf of Naples)
The President of the National Institute of Geophysics and Volcanology (INGV) was interviewed just a few hours after the magnitude 4.4 seismic event recorded in Campi Flegrei on May 21, 2026, at 5:50 AM, a tremor located offshore at a depth of 3 kilometers.
When asked by the journalist what citizens should do to continue living in this troubled area of Naples with a modicum of peace of mind, Director Prof. Florindo first clarified that people must follow official information coming from Civil Protection and the Vesuvius Observatory: trusting professionals is the first step toward living in an area characterized by seismic and volcanic risk. The President then recalled that two years earlier a Civil Protection drill (Exe Flegrei 2024) was coordinated by his institute to test and verify the emergency system across all its branches, including evacuation, involving roughly 1,500 citizens.
The drills also included setting up the DI.COMA.C (Command and Control Directorate) in the municipality of San Marco Evangelista (Caserta). The exercise went well, the geophysicist specified. Within that same framework, public information sessions were also organized by Civil Protection, though they appear not to have met with particular public attendance.
Continuing the interview, the head of INGV offered reassurance by noting that the Campi Flegrei volcanic field is one of the most closely monitored areas in the world, 24 hours a day, and that should magma move toward the surface, scientists would be able to detect it hours, if not days, in advance. Moreover, monitoring in the area is being upgraded by deploying stations offshore as well, in the submerged section of the caldera, thanks to six million euros allocated by Minister Bernini, head of the Ministry of University and Research.
A recent study has just noted in its premise that caldera volcanoes are characterized by eruptive hazards that, albeit occurring at low frequency, are generally of high magnitude. From a research standpoint, perhaps with a view to prevention, one must acknowledge that in the Phlegraean area it is unfortunately difficult to investigate the crustal thicknesses beneath the volcanic field, where magma has intruded at various levels and in different volumes, interconnecting through dynamics that remain to be fully understood. Understanding the geological processes inherent in the bowels of the Phlegraean caldera is indeed of fundamental importance in attempting to forecast volcanic risk.
Meanwhile, the shallow and deep crustal subsoil of the Campi Flegrei supervolcano appears to be characterized by intrusive magma located just a few kilometers beneath the surface, although the incandescent material seems modest and tentacular, to the point of not being easily distinguishable from its surroundings. In any event, this discreet intrusion of magma creeping into the top few kilometers interacts heavily with the thermal aquifers that are normally abundant and circulating in the semi-superficial part of the caldera. Overheated by magma and by magmatic gases seeping abundantly from depth, these aquifers generate massive amounts of steam, thus keeping local concern high for both phreatic and magmatic eruptions, given that a phreatic blast could serve as a harbinger of far worse trouble.
On the other hand, the physical interactions occurring primarily within the upper few kilometers generate extraordinarily high pressures, because steam expands enormously to an extent that also depends on the temperatures to which the water is subjected. This could mean that pockets of superheated steam, driven by surges of heat rising from depth, and particularly from intermediate magma accumulations located between 8 and 20 kilometers down, may build up pressure until reaching a critical or supercritical state.
Beyond that depth, down to the transition boundary between the crust and the mantle, lies the deep magmatic source. Here, primitive magmas accumulate, feeding the melt column and its storage reservoirs located at various depths. The deeper investigations probe, the harder it becomes to interpret the dynamic and chemical processes characterizing the caldera's subsoil. Thus, the problem of forecasting becomes even more complex, because what likely makes the difference is understanding how magma batches stored at different levels exchange material, as well as their ability to spread laterally into thin sheets (sills) within the subsoil before ascending.
Even though deep magmatic processes are not entirely clear, it is certain that the superheated steam generated by contact between water and magmatic heat, or its associated fluids, produces enormous pressures capable of deforming superficial strata up to the breaking point of the rock layers. At that moment, seismic waves are released, generating earthquakes that are dangerous precisely because they are shallow. Widespread fracturing of the rock strata should theoretically prevent massive accumulations of energy, yet at the same time the extensive fissuring of these very layers facilitates the upward passage of scorching fluids and magma fractions toward the surface. For now, however, the system as a whole is held together by a complex equilibrium that currently holds, yet could rupture suddenly, giving way to a true eruption after nearly 500 years of volcanic quiescence.
In predictive terms, roughly speaking in the absence of scientific certainties, we can say that the probability of generating a false eruptive alarm is 33.3%. There is equally a 33.3% chance of issuing an eruption forecast timely enough for evacuation, but there is also a 33.3% probability of facing a missed eruptive alarm or an alert issued below the minimum time threshold required for the emergency plan to succeed. On the other hand, Prof. Florindo of INGV stated that a forecast could be possible hours or days before the event occurs. From a purely scientific standpoint, "hours" undeniably remains a forecasting success. The fact that such an accurate forecast might fail to cover the evacuation timelines established in emergency plans is, frankly, not a scientific problem but a technical and administrative one, given that engineering and urban planning have other ways to reduce risk, such as mitigating population density by freezing residential construction. Planners can also act on the emergency and evacuation framework itself, improving it through pragmatic assessments rather than cosmetic arithmetic. For example, waiting one's turn to leave by car or shuttle bus is hardly an optimal strategy.
In any case, to sum up, in principle there is a 66.6% probability that the protection of the population will be safeguarded one way or another, inevitably accepting the possibility of a false alarm.
Remaining on the technical side, it must be noted that the drills conducted so far in Campi Flegrei have virtually no practical utility, because simulating the evacuation of roughly 1,500 residents out of 550,000 is incongruous. The figure of 1,500 corresponds to barely 0.27% of the total residents of the Campi Flegrei Red Zone. Moreover, there is already an unavoidable drill gap dictated by the calm demeanor of participants in the absence of real eruptive danger.
To make the futility of the aforementioned drills even clearer, we can use an analogy: testing a fire evacuation plan in a Type-5 school complex (1,200 students) with a 0.27% sample would correspond to moving barely 3 students out of the entire student body. With those numbers at school, at most you could test whether the school bell works...
As for the informational booths, one must bear in mind that the people of Pozzuoli and Naples have long understood that there are no deterministic forecasting certainties, and therefore find it superfluous to keep hearing the same talking points about what is effectively the "geology of maybes." Citizens would become far more engaged if they were involved in operational decisions, and above all they would take greater interest in Civil Protection's outreach if they received concrete answers regarding their post-eruption fate, should an emergency ever materialize. At present, a vague notion circulates that everyone will be relocated to the Campanian hinterland, yet nobody knows exactly where.
Unfortunately, science does not always advance in giant leaps, and today neither our knowledge of volcanic processes nor ultra-sophisticated monitoring instruments allow for a deterministic prediction of an eruptive event. Anyone choosing to live in the Phlegraean territories must therefore grasp that there are no absolute certainties, only probabilities, even though maximum scientific commitment is undoubtedly applied within the limits of current national and international knowledge. Yet some stubbornly insist on continuing to build inside the intra-caldera area, perhaps in a decentralized, camouflaged fashion, justified by necessity and the buzzword of "resilience," but still doggedly within the Phlegraean Red Zone: in places like Licola and its surroundings... Meanwhile, defining the general and restricted bradyseismic zones has fostered the misconception that those are the only truly dangerous areas in Campi Flegrei, also because far too little emphasis has been placed on magmatic eruption, despite the phenomenon being imminent and representing the true Sword of Damocles hanging over these territories.
Map of the Red and Yellow Zones of Campi Flegrei
As for the America’s Cup, with sailing races scheduled to begin on July 10, 2027, in the waters of the Gulf of Naples, logistical and operational bases as well as the village for the 5 competing teams are currently being completed in Bagnoli, right between the two volcanic zones. There is talk of seismic and eruptive risk for the competitors and their respective crews: in principle, overall risk is contained, because the structures housing boats and staff will presumably be built to anti-seismic standards, and if necessary, in the event of a volcanic alert, the sailing teams already possess the best possible means of transport to escape traffic gridlock, a racing yacht, ideally setting course toward Capri... As for the risk to spectators, given that the races are set to take place along the Caracciolo waterfront, those watching the regattas will actually be positioned south of the hilly boundary line of Campi Flegrei, in the Chiaia district, a location that allows for relatively easy evacuation, at least on foot.
                                                                                Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)


mercoledì 21 gennaio 2026

Eruptive Risk at Campi Flegrei: America First!

 

Nisida - Bagnoli: headquarters of the Allied Maritime Command Naples until 2013.

Some time ago, local Neapolitan newspapers reported that personnel at the US Navy base stationed in Naples were issued operational instructions on how to protect themselves from earthquakes or take shelter in the event of a possible volcanic eruption. This major US Navy logistical facility is located at Naples Capodichino (Airport), sitting in relative proximity to both the Mount Vesuvius and Campi Flegrei volcanic districts. These two fiery geographical sectors lie to the east and west of the city of Naples, respectively, and are characterized by a frequently explosive eruptive nature.

The handbook distributed to civilian staff and military families contains provisions from Naval Support Activity (NSA) Naples, stipulating, it seems, that in the event of an eruptive alert, the instructions, orders, and evacuation procedures issued by NSA Naples must take priority over other existing plans... America first!

                                   

The memorandum specifically brings Mount Vesuvius—and above all Campi Flegrei—into focus, as one cannot rule out a seismic resurgence inside the caldera acting as a precursor to an eruption, or at least the continuation of this unpredictable, ongoing geo-bradyseismic unrest capable of generating earthquakes. Knowing how to handle an earthquake is vital. Italy is a geologically young and restless land that must periodically contend with Apennine tectonics, as well as localized volcanic tectonics like that of Campi Flegrei, whose subsoil is characterized by the presence of magma and fluids in a supercritical state of temperature and pressure...

From a seismic emergency perspective, defending against crustal shaking means first and foremost acting on prevention by prioritizing all initiatives capable of structurally retrofitting the buildings where people live and work—military bases included.

Intervention plans for the bradyseismic zone and the restricted bradyseismic zone of Pozzuoli call for rapid structural inspections after every significant earthquake and, where necessary, inspecting engineers can order the evacuation of families from unsafe buildings, relocating them to hotels or facilities designated for this purpose outside the Red Zone.

Campi Flegrei: bradyseismic zones.

The area potentially swept by hazardous volcanic phenomena such as pyroclastic flows should presumably be circumscribed within a circle with a radius of about 10 kilometers from the presumed eruptive vent, covering a total circular area of 314 square kilometers.

These guidelines, however, hold validity only if we rely on the axiom that a potential eruptive event will be characterized by a low or medium Volcanic Explosivity Index—that is, not exceeding VEI 4, corresponding to a sub-Plinian style event. This eruptive style—considered the maximum plausible event pending any different assessment by the Major Risks Commission (Commissione Grandi Rischi)—is the benchmark adopted in emergency plans for both Neapolitan volcanic districts to delimit the boundaries of the two Red Zones to be evacuated if necessary.

If, on the other hand, the eruption were to manifest as a Plinian event—or in any case with a VEI 5 index, ten times larger than a VEI 4—it would pose a massive problem, as the eruption would generate a far wider Red Zone than the one adopted in current emergency plans, with violent phenomena capable of striking segments of the population not covered by preventive evacuation measures.

The opposite is also true: scientists estimate that, in the event of an eruption, the most probable outcome is a modest-scale event of the ultra-Strombolian type (VEI 3), similar to the one that characterized the birth of Monte Nuovo in Pozzuoli in 1538. Unfortunately, the Volcanic Explosivity Index (VEI) is a metric determined post-event, just as the timing of an eruption remains strictly probabilistic.

Outside the Red Zone, during a volcanic emergency, the situation for evacuees should be less dangerous provided they take care to avoid the downwind sector relative to the eruptive vent, where ash and lapilli fallout would be heavy, creating severe disruption and danger from the very first moments of the eruption. In other words, within the first 10 km from the eruptive center, one must as a rule evacuate preemptively to survive. Beyond those kilometers—and especially toward the east—one would face severe hardship, proportional to a person's position and distance from the crater.

Indeed, statistics based on observing prevailing wind directions across the two volcanic areas point to the eastern sectors as those most likely exposed to ash and lapilli fallout, which is why they are pre-classified in emergency plans as the Yellow Zone. During an eruption, pyroclastic products would be blasted high into the air by explosions and then carried by high-altitude winds until gravity pulls them down, forming deposits on rooftops and the ground, starting with the heaviest fragments. While for Vesuvius it is already possible to map the area that would bear the brunt of pyroclastic fallout, for Campi Flegrei this remains uncertain because the exact location of the eruptive vent—which might not even be single—is unknown.

Campi Flegrei: Red and Yellow Zones


Those who unwittingly find themselves beneath the ash cloud (Yellow Zone) would face breathing difficulties, eye irritation, stalled vehicle engines, and disorientation—without finding safe shelter inside buildings with flat roofs, since the accumulation of pyroclastic deposits could trigger dangerous, catastrophic roof collapses with a domino effect starting from the top floor. Finer ash particles, meanwhile, can drift through the atmosphere for hundreds or even thousands of kilometers.

In a volcanic emergency, one must carefully select essential survival supplies to take along. These will vary in type and quantity according to personal needs and, above all, the load capacity of one's vehicle—which should not be a truck, as heavy vehicles can obstruct traffic amidst frightened and impatient motorists. Ultimately, evacuating on foot cannot be ruled out either: a far from remote option should total gridlock occur. In any case, covering a distance of roughly 10 kilometers would require a march of nearly 3 hours, ideally moving in the opposite direction or perpendicular to the prevailing wind.

The US Sixth Fleet contingent in Campania appears to be stationed across Naples Capodichino, Giugliano (Lago Patria), and Gricignano d'Aversa. US Navy military personnel—and especially civilian staff—should in principle comply with the directives issued by the host country and respect the emergency and evacuation plan designed to safeguard the territory. Likely, since the American community would need to be repatriated to the United States in the event of an evacuation, they may have an autonomous organization to reach other US bases outside the volcanic risk perimeter in case of danger; the hope is that their movements will not conflict with the evacuation routes established by Italian Civil Protection.

Moreover, if US military personnel also had to relocate classified documents and electronic communications gear, it cannot be ruled out that they might operate differently from general emergency rules. As things stand, however, simply adopting pitched roofs could increase the resilience of troops inside the military facilities at Capodichino, with an evacuation order directed if necessary solely to non-combatants (NEO) and civilian personnel, as military staff might follow different protocols involving higher operational resilience. Obviously, during an eruption, flight operations at Capodichino Airport would be completely compromised and radio transmissions disrupted.

Traveling by car would allow taking along slightly bulkier items, though care must be taken not to compromise interior cabin space, which serves as the primary living shelter. In an eruption, the top priority is saving human lives, not possessions.

If conditions force an evacuation on foot, it will be wise to pack only water, cash, valuables, essential banking cards, and personal IDs into a backpack—alongside life-saving medications, a flashlight, and mobile phones (ideally with a spare power bank) to receive messages from Civil Protection (IT-Alert) and relatives. The most forward-thinking individuals will likely also bring FFP2 masks and protective goggles...

Generally speaking, provided the Volcanic Explosivity Index forecasts are respected, the American bases should not face exceptional hazards, as they actually lie outside the Red Zones and inside the Yellow Zones, where structural defenses are viable.

Within this context of armed forces exposed to volcanic hazard, it would be interesting to know the emergency plan prepared by the Italian Air Force Academy in Pozzuoli, which sits atop a 155-meter-high lava dome called Monte Olibano. Adjacent to the Solfatara volcano, this site—unlike the American base—is exposed to all volcanic phenomena regardless of the eruptive style. Presumably, the evacuation of the Academy would have to take place during the pre-alert phase, as there would be no sense in exposing cadets to the risks of a general alert phase. Relocating the Academy to facilities adjacent to Grazzanise Air Base might perhaps be a wise preventive decision.

                                                                            Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)