Translate

Visualizzazione post con etichetta Mount Marsili. Mostra tutti i post
Visualizzazione post con etichetta Mount Marsili. Mostra tutti i post

lunedì 27 maggio 2013

Mount Marsili: Will It Take Center Stage on May 21, 2011? (Note by Prof. Mastrolorenzo)

 



Some readers have written to us with a certain degree of concern because a prophecy stated by parascientists, as they are called, is circulating online and in the media claiming that on May 21, 2011, the Marsili volcano will produce an eruption accompanied by tsunami waves that would sweep across the southern part of our Peninsula facing the Tyrrhenian Sea. The scenarios outlined in this way go without saying are somewhat surreal.
Our reader Monica, in the comments section, asked several questions regarding Marsili and its intrinsic hazard.
Let us get to the answers. Mount Etna, by history and tradition, is a surface volcano of considerable importance and is thoroughly monitored. As for Marsili, due to its location and recent history, we doubt it can be monitored in physical and chemical terms on par with what is already done for Etna. It must also be said that recently, partly on the heels of unjustified alarmism, attention on Europe's largest volcano has been growing sharply.
Our reader Monica, of course, through her questions intended to understand whether we are in a position to predict a volcanic eruption well in advance. Volcanic eruptions are not mathematically predictable, either in the long or medium term. In the short and very short term, instead, it may be possible to venture hypotheses that could nevertheless turn out to be fallacious in the end.
Even if Marsili were to erupt, a distance of over one hundred kilometers from the coast with an overlying water column of four hundred and fifty meters should represent a substantial safety buffer to consider peninsular populations safe from the most violent and destructive volcanic phenomena.
Regarding Marsili, therefore, more than the eruption itself, tsunami risk has been highlighted as a concrete element of concern, which experts say could be generated by collapse landslides detaching from the underwater slopes of the submerged mountain.
Such collapses could originate during an eruption, an earthquake, or even through processes naturally tied to gravity and its equilibria.
To understand the problem in conceptual terms, just think of what happens in a swimming pool: our bulky friend who dives headfirst into the water will generate waves. If the same person climbs slowly down the ladder, the water will remain substantially still. A landslide, therefore, in the case of events tied to this type of phenomenon and remotely hypothesized for Marsili, in order to produce rogue waves would have to be volumetrically (in cubic meters) very large, with sustained detachment and impact velocity, to displace masses of water from the seabed that would then travel in the form of waves. Predicting an eruption is a gamble. Predicting a landslide is even more so. Indicating the exact date of a calamity is beyond all scientific logic.
We asked Professor Giuseppe Mastrolorenzo, a volcanology expert, for a note that would serve as an answer to our reader Monica, as well as to all our readers living with anxiety over a prophecy, that of the end of the world at the hands of Marsili on May 21, 2011, which, despite having no basis in terms of forecasting, has wrongly turned out to be a news story of great journalistic impact.
Professor Mastrolorenzo's opinion is as follows:
"Volcanological knowledge regarding Marsili is still limited, and only recently has the creation of a monitoring network comparable to those of other active Italian volcanoes been hypothesized.
At present, there are no elements to believe that modifications of volcanological, geochemical, or geophysical parameters concerning Marsili have occurred or are underway. In strictly scientific terms, therefore, there is nothing new! In this regard, I suggest a very simple and universally valid criterion to understand whether a given news item regarding the risk of earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, landslides, or tsunamis may have scientific grounding. Adopt the rule that any news item concerning one of such events that also reports the exact day on which it will occur must be completely ignored. This is because with current scientific knowledge it is absolutely impossible to predict an eruption, an earthquake, or other related events that even include an indication of the date. We speak, in fact, always of generic probabilities that the event may occur within a more or less long interval, but never of certainty."
                                                                            Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)

Marsili and the Nightmare of May 21, 2011

 

It seems that the alarm regarding the possibility that on May 21, 2011, the end of the world might come, or in any case that of southern Italy or perhaps of all the countries overlooking the Mediterranean, due to a tsunami wave generated by the submarine volcano Marsili, has been met by more than a few people with apprehension.
There are also those who move their anxieties forward to May 11, because another prophecy foretells a catastrophic earthquake in the Rome area: it is said to be a prediction by Raffaele Bendandi, though there is no certainty.
How a Tsunami Is Born: Earthquakes, Landslides, and Eruptions
A tsunami wave can generally be associated with three calamitous events: a strong earthquake located at sea or close to it; a marine or submarine volcanic eruption; or a substantial mass, usually rocky, plunging into water, even more so if rapidly. Specifically, it could be a meteorite or a landslide breaking off from a mountain or, in our case (Marsili), from a volcano. Obviously, at the base of the "tsunami system" two fundamental elements concur: considerable energy and the sea. In reality, we have also had landslides displacing masses of water on dry land.
The Vajont tragedy, in 1963, was caused precisely by the overflow of a huge quantity of water from an artificial basin (dam), due to a landslide (over 250 million cubic meters) that broke off from Mount Toc. The rogue wave (let us improperly call it that) that was generated exceeded the edge of the dam by about 100 meters in height, rushing downstream in a course that destroyed villages and caused massive loss of life.
A strong earthquake is the phenomenon we are perhaps most accustomed to associating as the cause of a tsunami. Movements along the edges of faults located on the seabed, in fact, have the capacity, under certain conditions, to impart a vigorous motion to the overlying masses of seawater. Waves with this origin travel hundreds and hundreds of kilometers at high speed before crashing onto coastal stretches, which are overrun by the imperious advance of the waters even for several kilometers inland.
In Italy, the tidal wave most cited in texts is the one that occurred on December 28, 1908, following a very violent earthquake (10th degree Mercalli), which shattered the cities of Reggio Calabria and Messina. The most recent one, instead, was just a few years ago (2002): a landslide breaking off from the steep slopes of Stromboli caused a rogue wave with predominantly local effects and without harming people who, fortunately and due to the winter season, were not exposed on the beaches.
Volcanic eruption can in turn create a tsunami. The Krakatoa volcano, located between the islands of Java and Sumatra, was a spectacular protagonist from this standpoint with its 1883 eruption, defined as the largest ever to occur in historical times. It caused towering waves, even several tens of meters high, which swept the nearby islands from coast to coast. One ship, according to chronicles of the time, was hurled directly into the jungle. There were multiple waves and, as mentioned, of considerable heights. After the eruption, nothing remained of the volcanic island of Krakatoa except a few shreds of land.
Earthquake Forecasts, Marsili, and the Real Danger of Mount Vesuvius
The theories of the illustrious Bendandi on earthquake prediction, instead, relate to astral cycles and conjunctions (generalizing) as the cause of lithospheric upheavals. Without delving into subjects we do not know well, we note that a possible and not excludable astral component that facilitates lithospheric imbalances and equilibria, through attractions, alignments, conjunctions, and so forth, in terms of causes and effects would have to be correlated in detail to all terrestrial variables of the lithosphere. Interrelations, therefore, very difficult to interpret, quantify, and decipher, to the point of making the path of pinpoint or near pinpoint earthquake prediction through the movement of celestial bodies substantially impracticable.
However, if these prophecies or predictions, as one wishes to call them, should prove reliable, give or take a day (though we feel confident in ruling it out), it would be a true revolution and an epochal defeat for the most prestigious national and international scientific academies. We fear this is not the case. We fear that earthquake prediction is still an imperfect science, even if some techniques, such as those introduced by researcher Giuliani, deserve broad experimental consideration.
Unfortunately, neither is the medium or long term prediction of volcanic eruptions yet a reality. In the short and very short term, the reliability percentages of estimates on eruptive times reach interesting figures, yet not mathematical certainty. Even worse is the prediction of a landslide detaching from a height, especially if submarine as in the case of Marsili.
All these phenomena we have mentioned can occur today, tomorrow, or the day after tomorrow, or even in a millennium or two: it is not given to know. We move on hypotheses with respect to a dynamic system (the Earth) in search of equilibrium.
On the Marsili volcano, it is best that those who study it speak out rather than parascientists. On the other hand, the volcano has not erupted for quite a long time. This means that the signs of the notorious landslides, as producers of tsunamis, can all be found on the seabed. In this way we would have an idea not only of the quantity of materials detaching from the mountain, but also of the numerical quantity of landslide events that have occurred so far. It would be a good starting point to intuit the risks deriving from Marsili, as well as from its quiescent "companions." All volcanoes that must be the subject of increasingly targeted studies, to gather useful data to quantify risk levels for exposed populations.
On the other hand, every now and then news arrives that some new volcano has been identified in the Tyrrhenian Sea. It would therefore be desirable to first prioritize a seabed sounding plan with the creation of thematic maps. Secondly, to define the volcanic apparatuses to be monitored and the best system to do so. Spending a fortune to monitor a single volcano without knowing if there are others and whether the known ones can rise to become a problem might not be the best solution.
A reflection must then be made in the general discussion: what reliability can a technical and political system like ours offer, where alarmism is raised over a submarine volcano (Marsili) located 150 kilometers from the Campanian coasts and still to be studied and, therefore, still to be evaluated in its entirety in terms of risk, while nothing is done for Mount Vesuvius, on whose belly six hundred thousand "sleeping" inhabitants slumber at zero distance? Yet on the danger of Mount Vesuvius everyone agrees: parascientists and scientists, statistics, and even common sense.
Who then sows alarmism with the story of Marsili? Certainly not those who study it. The Latins, to identify a culprit, started from a beautiful concept: cui prodest? (who benefits?)
                                                                                Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)