Translate

Visualizzazione post con etichetta Evacuation Plans. Mostra tutti i post
Visualizzazione post con etichetta Evacuation Plans. Mostra tutti i post

lunedì 2 giugno 2025

Eruptive Risk in Campi Flegrei: The Volcanic Danger Goes Unperceived

Rione Terra - Pozzuoli

Campi Flegrei is a vast volcanic caldera characterizing a corner of the Planet, as well as the western metropolitan area of Naples, where major eruptions can occur in what is effectively a supervolcano. The last eruptive event dates back to 1538 and was of modest size. In any case, for 487 years the crust, despite tremors, bulges, and degassing, has managed to contain the magmatic masses packed roughly 8 to 10 kilometers beneath the caldera subsoil without giving way to outbursts. Since this is a fairly fractured crustal cover, some hypothesize that a magmatic intrusion may have infiltrated up to about 3 kilometers from the surface. This condition would bring an additional heat contribution to the hydrothermal waters already superheated by magmatic fluids, further favoring the phenomenon of bradyseism and associated seismicity. The official body responsible for volcanic monitoring (INGV), however, rules out this intrusive possibility.

From the very same cracks in the shallow crust, at certain points a large quantity of predominantly magmatic gases is released, such as carbon dioxide and hydrogen sulfide: gaseous substances pushed to the surface that spread into the air especially in conjunction with seismic events that further fissure the crust and shake up the carbonated waters. Internal pressures within the shallow crust deform the rock layers until they fracture, inducing earthquakes which, even if not of high magnitude, are in any case fearsome due to the shallowness of their hypocenters. Damage is generally attributable to the quality of buildings and the characteristics of foundation soils.
A Multi Hazard Area with Unknown Return Periods
Delving into the natural themes that characterize this territory, let us say right away that the Phlegraean caldera area is a multi hazard zone, with phenomena of varying extent, intensity, and danger, distinguished by the vast difference existing between each individual natural manifestation, and by the return intervals of the phenomena, which cannot be quantified. Obviously, as long as bradyseism persists, all the phenomenology associable with bradyseism, which is tied to the Phlegraean magmatic root, persists as well. Therefore, it should be quite clear that an eruption is an event that cannot be overlooked: it remains in fact a phenomenal, powerful, and naturally and unfortunately immanent event in these places.

FENOMENO:

Eruzione vulcanica

Terremoti

Bradisismo

Emanazioni gassose

ULTIMA MANIFESTAZIONE:

1538

Mm > 2

23/05/2025

In corso

In corso

TEMPI DI RITORNO:

Ignoti

Ignoti

Ignoti

Ignoti



All these phenomena tied to Phlegraean volcanism, with shallow and deep implications, are effectively imponderable, and therefore it is not possible to venture forecasts on the unfolding of events, which are all offspring of the famous concept of Panta rei. The not very reassuring observation is that all the reported types of danger, with symptoms of varying intensity, are to some extent to be considered inevitable, at least as long as the subsoil of Campi Flegrei holds a substantial magmatic base at a depth of tens of kilometers. Moreover, the molten rocks extend all the way to the Vesuvian subsoil, in what appears to be a single, vast magma chamber: "a great lake of magma" the media declared about ten years ago, even though there is no evidence of mutual interference between the two volcanic districts.
According to an eminent academic from Salerno, instead, the eruptions of the last millennia in Campi Flegrei have been waning in power, and from the deformations of the magma chamber one can gather that the magma volumes involved are not excessive and can be estimated at one hundred million cubic meters: like a small hill. The expert goes on to state that in the event of an eruption, an occurrence similar to that of 1538 is expected. In reality, the magma volumes involved in that latter eruption were decidedly smaller than those cited by the expert. If a 1538 type eruption were to occur beneath a city, according to the associate professor, and it is self evident, problems would certainly not be lacking. The expectation of an eruption similar to the one that gave birth to Monte Nuovo (133 meters high) is shared without official confirmation by several scientists. Emergency plans, however, as we must remember, are calibrated on a maximum sub Plinian type event (VEI 4).
The phenomenon worrying Phlegraean populations, particularly those of Pozzuoli, is the bradyseismic episodes that have characterized these places for centuries. In the recent past, the bradyseismic crises of 1969/1972 and then that of 1982/1984 stand out. The third bradyseismic episode, namely the current one, began quietly in 2005, but with gradually increasing intensity that became concerning starting in 2018. The maximum ground uplift of 145 centimeters, a provisional measurement, is recorded on the seabed about 500 meters south of Rione Terra (Pozzuoli). A possible reversal of bradyseism, which could become downward, would greatly mitigate the seismic component. Even in this case, however, the volcanic danger would remain intact.
Why Our Senses Do Not Perceive the Eruptive Danger
Approaching the topic of risk from a technical standpoint as well, it must be emphasized that in the Phlegraean area only earthquakes and gas emissions of hydrogen sulfide, due to their characteristic smell of rotten eggs, are perceptible to the senses. Earthquakes are therefore the phenomenon that captures the greatest attention of the population, because of the direct perceptibility of the energy released in the area by crustal tremors, which cannot be influenced in any way by environmental conditions.
The other phenomenon, that of underground gas emissions spreading into the air, as mentioned, can only be detected by smell for its hydrogen sulfide component: as for carbon dioxide, instead, it should be remembered that it is an odorless and colorless gas, heavier than air, and generally detectable only with specialized instruments. Ground uplift, furthermore, is an extremely slow phenomenon, equal to roughly 0.05 mm per day, a rate that can also vary over time, yet in all cases is not directly perceptible physically by the population. If it were, the danger would be at its maximum and it would be time to run for it.
The perception of an alarming phenomenon is certainly a complex process inherent to living beings and therefore to humans, yet fundamental to understanding and interpreting, through the processing of information provided by the senses, the dangers arising from the surrounding environment. The response to danger is often flight, which is not always reasoned and at times is rash: frequently dictated by psychological pressure that undermines mental clarity when under threat. The diagram below highlights the difference between an evacuation plan and a relocation plan: the behavioral key is proportional to the intensity with which the senses perceive the harmful or lethal phenomenon, with the variable dictated by the information available on the characteristics of the danger.
The perception of danger through the senses determines whether the plan will be
for relocation or evacuation
The administrative component at various levels, as well as the scientific one, seems oriented toward disconnecting the natural phenomena mentioned earlier from eruptive risk in the collective understanding. This is a necessity considered strategic, likely to favor resilience policies in the face of earthquakes, which are deemed the real problem to address in the bradyseismic intervention zone. Apparently, such policies seem convincing, yet it is precisely this shrewd selection of hazards that allowed Minister Musumeci to state that there are decades of delay in volcanic risk prevention. Riding the seismic theory alone, therefore, is a modus operandi that ensures popular consensus, yet can be disproven at any moment; in any case, these are not maneuvers of great statesmanship, because they can undermine the future safety needs of the intracaldera population.
At the root of the lower sensitivity toward eruptive risk, perhaps also dictated by a psychological need to forget it, lies the lack of sensory perception of volcanic hazard. This is a danger that receives analytical reporting rather than being directly perceived in the absence of an eruptive column, through information processes involving various institutions and administrations, often using a single track language skewed toward all area hazards except the volcanic one.
In the Phlegraean area, there are geophysical and geochemical signals that can be framed as pre eruptive precursors. Well, these signals, moreover uncorroborated by past evaluative statistics that could indicate the trend of phenomena, are all present in the Phlegraean area, and lately an increase in phenomenology has also been noted in the submarine environment. It must be clarified, however, that even though we are in the presence of well established geophysical and geochemical imbalances in the Phlegraean subsoil, these signals can continue for years without an eruption occurring, just as in a short time they could indicate a pre eruptive condition. In any case, there are no deterministic guarantees regarding what may happen geologically.
Structural Prevention, DICOMAC, and Walking Escape Routes
In the face of so much indecision regarding the forecasting of the eruptive phenomenon, despite routine non binding reassurances as evidenced by the bulletins issued by the Vesuvius Observatory, the only initiatives toward area safety that would make sense concern structural prevention as a passive strategy to reduce exposed value (VE), and concrete evacuation planning as an active protective tool to separate the population from eruptive danger within a few hours.
Evacuation allows, when necessary, placing a safe distance (d) between the population and the volcanic hazard
Starting from the premise that the caldera is physically immovable, in order to separate men and women from eruptive danger, when necessary before the blasts manifest with harshness, an evacuation plan must be carried out. Out of necessity, one must therefore act on the exposed value, namely the population (550,000 inhabitants), which will have to be moved when needed to a distance (d) of about 10 to 15 kilometers from the boundaries of the volcanic Red Zone. The Command and Control Directorate (DICOMAC) of the Civil Protection Department, for example, the governing body that will activate modularly to manage the pre alarm and fully in the event of an alarm, is located about 30 kilometers northeast of Pozzuoli. A place that, by geographical position and distance, should be immune from eruptive phenomena: the same cannot be said for the headquarters of the Vesuvius Observatory. In any case, even on foot, in about 3 hours, there is the possibility of getting out of reach of the most deleterious effects of a volcanic eruption. This means that marking pedestrian routes to exit the Red Zone could be a last resort tactic to avoid being caught unprepared should the eruption begin to manifest in a context of vehicular traffic completely compromised by chaos. On the other hand, the 1632 Portici plaque addressed to posterity speaks clearly about the behavior to adopt when residing within the range of a volcano.
                                                                                    Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)



mercoledì 21 maggio 2025

Eruptive Risk in Campi Flegrei: The Seething Subsoil

 

Campi Flegrei
Taking stock of the volcanic hazard of Campi Flegrei with all its connected phenomena is truly an arduous task, especially when analyzing the various scientific theories on the subject, which range across conjectures that are sometimes at odds with one another.
Regarding the ground uplift processes, a phenomenon better known as bradyseism, scientists seem to agree that it is attributable to the massive presence of water in the subsoil, of rainwater, marine, and also endogenous origin, which, struck by the scorching fluids released from the magma, expands in volume and transforms into superheated steam in a supercritical condition, capable of pressing and deforming the rock layers toward the most yielding part. It is precisely these rock thicknesses deforming until they reach their breaking point that produce seismic waves with hypocenters often geographically located within the bradyseismic area. This zone is the sector most affected by earthquakes which, due to the ductility of hot rocks and fracturing of the crust, should be of contained magnitude. Nevertheless, given the shallowness of the hypocenters, the earthquakes manifest with vigorous crustal shaking. Obviously, the difference in terms of damage is then made by the quality of the buildings.
Pozzuoli: bradyseismic zone (light blue) and restricted bradyseismic zone (lilac)

The point of maximum deformation and perhaps yielding of the rock layers characterizing the first few kilometers of the subsoil seems to correspond more or less to Rione Terra (Pozzuoli), which among other things records the peak of the uplift at about 145 centimeters, clearly visible inside the fishermen's dock, which now shows patches of seabed completely dry.
Pozzuoli: fishermen's dock
Supercritical Water and Magma: What Drives Bradyseism?
The community of academics interested in the Phlegraean area seems to agree that the crucible of thermodynamic interactions is located roughly 3 to 4 kilometers beneath the surface. Due to pressure and temperature, the water circulating in the subsoil is thought to be in a supercritical state, partly because of the intense heat that may also originate from wisps of magma pushed up to this depth, which directly or indirectly heat the circulating fluids, also keeping the risk of phreatic eruptions high.
The points of greatest scientific uncertainty concern the exact position of the magma, namely its depth and its direct influence on bradyseism. Many naturally place it in the magma chamber at about 8 to 9 kilometers deep. Others believe it has also expanded in intrusive form at roughly 3 kilometers underground. Still others neither rule out nor confirm this possibility, whereas the INGV Volcanoes Department has categorically ruled out the presence of magma at shallow depths in the Phlegraean area, thereby aiming to emphasize that there is no short term eruptive danger, until proven otherwise.
This certainty, welcomed by Red Zone administrators, is not at all reassuring, because during the 79 AD Plinian eruption of Mount Vesuvius, magma rose to the surface directly from the magma chamber located tens of kilometers deep in a very short time. The INGV Volcanoes Department could therefore clarify whether eruptive mechanisms similar to those mentioned for Vesuvius can occur in Campi Flegrei, and whether they reiterate and confirm the idea that, to reach an eruptive event, magma in Campi Flegrei must first accumulate a few kilometers below the surface before bursting forth following further stress.
State of Emergency, Bagnoli, and the Myth of "Resilience"
All water! say some scientists, while local and regional administrators add that buildings in the general and restricted bradyseismic zone held up well during the recent seismic upheavals of May 13, 2025: and that is good news. A reassuring statement made for the cameras, perhaps to defuse Minister Musumeci's intention to declare a state of emergency, which also entails binding provisions for administrators and the population.
The minister's intention to declare a state of emergency has currently been shelved, because Musumeci had to back down, seemingly following strong pressure from local authorities not to proceed with the state of emergency in order to safeguard the tourist season. We must therefore acknowledge that even in the field of risk management, the prevailing philosophy is that safety is not an absolute good, but must be weighed according to cost benefit criteria, often invoked by the very same administrators who nevertheless ask for funds by waving that same banner denied to Musumeci. From a technical standpoint, cost benefit logic could be acceptable in our case only if everything possible had been done to avoid adding even a single extra person to the high volcanic risk calderopolis: otherwise it is pure cynicism. From this perspective, we fear concrete pouring ventures on the Bagnoli plain, in the name of the world's most important sailing race to be held in Naples in a couple of years.
Campi Flegrei: the Bagnoli plain
In the absence of scientific opinions regarding the mechanisms and timescales of magma ascent from deep levels, any disquisition meant to concretely reassure citizens about the effectiveness of the highly technological hyper instrumentation deployed in Campi Flegrei remains a pure rhetorical exercise. The instruments, they say, can provide very precise yet useful data to allow oversight bodies to interpret them, thereby catching any upward movements of magma at the outset.
It also comes to mind that, if bradyseism arises from the combination of two factors, water and heat, the current resurgence in terms of seismic intensity and reduction of quiet intervals could find its cause or contributing cause in the dynamics that ultimately concern the thermal gradient. Evidence in this regard is provided by satellite surveillance, which has detected an increase in ground temperature in Campi Flegrei in the days preceding stronger than usual earthquakes.
The dissertation regarding the presence or absence of intrusive magma in the first few kilometers does not gain much traction, because the issue is reduced to a scientific debate oriented more toward the genesis of bradyseism than toward eruptive danger. Careful reflection, however, should lead to the understanding that we are facing a major methodological error, because bradyseismic phenomena could be the Trojan horse introducing eruptive risk to over half a million people without them concretely realizing it, since unlike earthquakes, the population does not physically perceive eruptive danger, and therefore focuses mostly on what it directly feels (earthquakes), especially if steered to do so by the media.
Generalizing, scientific, administrative, and institutional authorities, with the exception of Minister Musumeci who appears fairly attentive to eruptive danger, seem to steer information predominantly toward the seismic bradyseismic angle, because it is a phenomenon that plays into the logic of building renovations to be subsidized with public money. In the Phlegraean area, quite a few citizens' associations have formed that applaud and call for territorial resilience through government financial commitment. Strangely, the Partenoflegreo committee as well as citizens' committees deem it plausible to invest inside the caldera of the supervolcano, because the belief circulates that once seismic risk is reduced with earthquake resistant buildings, Campi Flegrei can be considered a place where one can live and raise one's children with greater safety. A safety that, in truth, however desirable, nobody can guarantee in these places characterized by severe geological uncertainties. A series of signals leads one to believe that in the caldera subsoil there are dynamics evolving continuously, which still remain completely to be deciphered and defined regarding what could be a possible increased hazard or vice versa.
On the other hand, the Phlegraean population bases its so called resilience on a fundamental point that also serves as a fig leaf for certain public figures who do not want to acknowledge certain uncomfortable truths. The foremost element of all is scientific moral suasion, which claims to be able to detect the potential and threatening ascent of magma from the depths through the finest instrumental technology characterized by multiparametric stations that have now been refinanced. Certainly, hoped for forecasting success cannot be ruled out, quite the opposite: yet the unknown of the eruptive vent or vents still remains, as do phreatic risk, ground uplift, gas emissions, and local seismicity. The phenomena in the Phlegraean area will end when the magmatic furnace dies out: unfortunately, it is feared that this will not happen in the coming years.
The Evacuation Dilemma: Is Campania's Hinterland Ready?
Another cornerstone gaining ground concerns evacuation, which remains, when necessary, the only protective measure against eruptive risk. From the Parliamentary Intergroup for Southern Development, Fragile Areas, and Smaller Islands, a proposal is spreading with considerable publicity to modify current evacuation plans to make it feasible, in case of need, to relocate Neapolitan populations subject to volcanic risk toward the depopulated inland areas of Campania, via autonomous transfers by private car. A mandatory method, we might say, because roads and means of communication with Campania's hinterland are truly minimal.
The Intergroup, through the Convivenza Vesuvio foundation, seems to have already promoted the signing of memoranda of understanding with several municipalities in the Vesuvian area, proposing right now to the Civil Protection Department drills involving at least 10,000 citizens in the first demonstrative round. It is only logical that what is being proposed for the Vesuvian area will very soon be proposed again for Campi Flegrei as well.
Routing populations fleeing a volcanic emergency toward a series of municipalities in the Caserta, Benevento, Avellino, and Salerno provinces can certainly be a measure that could meet the needs of the population, which does not want to be diverted indefinitely toward other distant regions. In reality, the relocation of citizens who must be moved for safety reasons should be a step following the emergency, outside of emergency logic and timeframes.
Probably, and with this premise, such an initiative should be managed by organizations other than Civil Protection, more closely tied to territorial governance. The Civil Protection Department already needs to refine the existing evacuation plan, which has operational bugs, yet the existing minimum cannot be overturned in the name of a regional relocation that is currently more than approximate, as well as of dubious effectiveness. It must be remembered that the inhabitants remaining in the municipalities of Campania's hinterland are the custodians of centuries old traditions that cannot and must not be disrupted by those who might have to live in that territory, though not by choice. Our impression is that the yet to be defined initiative of allocating fleeing populations to the municipalities of Campania's hinterland has no practical feasibility prerequisites, only theoretical ones. Within a volcanic emergency, the philosophy of hospitality provides for accommodation in safe places that, despite a thousand difficulties, have the capacity to deliver essential services that are part of our ordinary life: school, work, healthcare, and mobility. Had these elements been present, these Apennine areas probably would not have become depopulated.
The mayor of Portici is an example of likeable operational shrewdness. Compared to his other Vesuvian colleagues, he seems to be moving on his own to find, in the event of a volcanic emergency, agreements for lasting hospitality in the coastal municipalities of Cilento.
                                                                    Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)