| The Solfatara crater, Pozzuoli |
On November 4, 2025, the Major Risks Commission met to assess the state of geovolcanic unrest in Campi Flegrei. Simultaneously, following established automatic protocols, the Civil Protection Department set the corresponding operational phase.
Within this technical and scientific body, the yellow alert level was thus ratified and proclaimed for the Phlegraean area under the new classification, representing an alert for medium disequilibrium in the caldera subsoil of the supervolcano. This confirmed the adoption of Phase 2 for the corresponding operational activities, which in any case appear to be actions that are not particularly burdensome compared to the complications that would have to be faced in the unfortunate event of moving to subsequent phases.
The map below highlights the area where the phenomena just mentioned, understood as volcanic precursors or in any case as processes reshaping the chemical and physical equilibria incessantly occurring in the caldera subsoil, can manifest with a certain intensity, incidence, persistence, and danger.
It is quite evident that the purple area entirely traces the boundaries of the restricted and extended bradyseismic zone, which has a total population of about 85,000 inhabitants residing, let us remember, in an area characterized in its deep subsoil by magma and a pressurized hydrothermal system. The radial center of the bradyseism corresponds to Rione Terra in Pozzuoli, which is also the point that has risen the most over the last twenty years, by almost 150 cm in height.
![]() |
Bradyseismic zone |
The Risk of a "Color Jump" and the Need for a Plan B
The Major Risks Commission has clarified that alert levels represent an index tied to variations in the physical and chemical parameters of the volcano, which give rise, according to a theoretically progressive trend, to potential eruptive hazard or in any case to a resurgence of phenomena that cannot be underestimated in terms of danger.
Nevertheless, given the impossibility of eliminating all the uncertainties that exist in geovolcanological matters, it cannot be ruled out that transitions from one alert level to another may occur on a nonlinear timeline, just as we could even face a color jump. For example, we could jump directly from medium yellow to red. Obviously, this latter eventuality could throw population evacuation plans into total crisis, which, let us remember, are based on an available timeframe of 72 hours. On the other hand, a jump in the alert level directly to red would trigger the operational evacuation alarm phase with overlapping functions and procedures that would surely be detrimental to the overall organization of rescue efforts, which in a context of widespread panic would also have to empty hospitals, clinics, museums, and prisons simultaneously with the Red Zone population of 550,000 residents. Moreover, let us not be fooled by the purple area: if a single or multiple eruption were to occur right in this sector, the initial blasts would manifest here, but pyroclastic products would disperse at high altitude for tens of kilometers before falling back down, and scorching pyroclastic flows would spread well beyond the boundaries of the purple semicircle.
These possibilities, however minimal, of having to suddenly face an eruptive alarm should prudently advise creating a Plan B containing instructions for leaving the Phlegraean area even in an emergency condition dictated by the clear perception of pre eruptive precursors, if not indeed with an eruption already underway.
It must be said that, especially in this volcanic district where due to centuries of quiescence there is no certain data on the quantity, quality, and duration of the precursors preceding an eruption, forecasting the eruptive phenomenon inevitably remains a probabilistic process, where false alarms or missed alarms cannot be ruled out. On the other hand, it is not even possible to assess the intensity of the eruption in advance.
Not even the highly advanced monitoring instrumentation managed by the Vesuvius Observatory can guarantee forecasting reliability. This is because electronic equipment does not make forecasts, it produces numbers, of absolute precision, yet still numbers, and precisely because there are no codified reference values or past experiences, forecasting the volcanic event here and in general still remains today a "manual" procedure in the hands of the Major Risks Commission. This also means that perhaps there is not that direct control over magma and its eventual ascent that we have been told about in recent years.
That there had to be an increase in the volcanic alert level in Campi Flegrei was a given and was already in the thoughts of the Major Risks Commission, established in 2023, and had they not widened the threshold mesh by duplicating the colors, perhaps today we would already be in orange territory. Indeed, the data confirm a steady increase in bradyseism with an uplift in recent weeks of 2.5 cm per month and a related increase in seismicity counting 165 earthquakes in the week from November 3 to 9, 2025. The hydrothermal system also records an increase in temperatures, pressures, and fumarolic gas fluxes dispersed into the atmosphere. Variations that certainly cannot leave indifferent those tasked with guaranteeing safety at all levels.
Prevention Over "Intracaldera Resilience"
The element that leaves us perplexed, as always, is tied to the use made of geochemical and geophysical data as a whole, which ultimately are used single mindedly only to represent hazard levels and operational phases. A table labeled alert levels that has a dramatic apex should have consequences not only in the operational response, which is frankly and inevitably limited given all the uncertainties governing the subject, but data on the hazard of the caldera area should first and foremost be used to encourage the prevention of a volcanic catastrophe, especially by those appointed to govern the volcanic territory.
Yet political authorities, contrary to non electoral logic, speak of resilience, bonuses, superbonuses, state and European funding, proposing residential persistence unfortunately cloaked in risk. It is worth remembering that even by reinforcing buildings to the maximum, they offer no defense against an eruption that could generate pyroclastic flows from one or more eruptive vents that cannot be identified beforehand. Nor is one immune from the danger of gases released from the subsoil, especially in conjunction with seismic stimulation. On the other hand, even buildings reinforced like a bunker must reckon with an uplift bradyseism and the risk of phreatic eruptions, especially in areas where the hydrothermal component is clearly evident.
Buildings that are already uninhabitable today should perhaps remain so, and owners would perhaps do well to request the assignment of a home outside the Red Zone, so as to guarantee themselves residential peace of mind. Authorities should not wedge themselves and get bogged down in monetizable compensation practices, because the system of values and presumed or real adjustments between the parties tends to get jammed despite the mediation of local authorities, which at times is not decisive, quite the opposite. The State, then, should perhaps offer homes in safe places rather than money that is hard to quantify and spend.
Vincenzo Savarese (MalKo)



Nessun commento:
Posta un commento
I commenti sono moderati dall'autore prima della pubblicazione. Non sono ammessi link pubblicitari o esterni.