Translate

domenica 20 dicembre 2020

Mount Vesuvius Risk and Hazard: The Red Zone, the Yellow Zone, and the Blue Zone.

Vesuvius
Those who search for information about Mount Vesuvius usually do so because they are drawn to the historical, natural, and archaeological features crowding the area around the world famous volcano. Equally keen interest is shown by researchers focused on the technical and scientific factors underlying the division of the volcanic perimeter into zones of varying hazard levels. This classification is based on the phenomena that could affect a vast portion of the Vesuvian area, taking into account the principle that every eruption involves an expulsive phase followed by the deposition of magmatic materials.
By analyzing the pyroclastic products accumulated on the ground all around the volcano at various depths and distances, it has been possible to determine, with a good degree of approximation, the eruptive intensity of past historical and protohistoric eruptions, as well as the distances traveled by pyroclastic flows sliding downslope and by ash and lapilli dispersed into the atmosphere and carried by the winds.
The analysis of past phenomena is crucial, because the underlying assumption guiding safety experts in their protective assessments is that what happened hundreds of years ago can happen again in the future, even though the recurrence intervals of eruptive events are not constant due to the countless variables at play in deep magmatic dynamics.
The phenomena expected during an eruption of Mount Vesuvius heavily depend on the Volcanic Explosivity Index (VEI), which can reach a value of 3, 4, or even 5. The latter is the maximum known level, corresponding to a Plinian eruptive style similar to the one that literally buried the town of Pompeii in 79 AD.
What type of eruption the next one will be, and when it will occur, are two questions that cannot be answered today. Nevertheless, to reach the surface, the magma will presumably have to force its way through old and new pathways, with an intrusion rate that will generate a series of precursors likely to be detected with enough lead time (hopefully) to issue warnings. Unfortunately, within the realm of possibilities, neither a false alarm nor a missed alarm, though statistically less likely, can be entirely ruled out.
As for the Volcanic Explosivity Index (VEI), it cannot be predetermined in advance, because the volumes of the magma masses involved, along with their distinct chemical and physical properties, are factors closely guarded within the unreachable depths of the Earth. Indeed, where the magma is stored, not even the most technological and innovative surveys can currently probe kilometers beneath the surface to assign a precise three dimensional, and therefore volumetric, value to the semi molten rocks. In the absence of detailed data, therefore, forecasting eruptive intensity remains an incomplete science.
Focusing solely on the most hazardous phenomena, namely pyroclastic flows (or density currents) and pyroclastic fallout, one must carefully consider the table below, which demonstrates how the impossibility of determining the Volcanic Explosivity Index in advance creates an operational vulnerability in the protective strategies and tactics to be adopted, or already in place.

Potential eruptive scenarios at Mount Vesuvius. Current civil protection plans are calibrated on a Sub-Plinian event (VEI 4), leaving an operational gap in the event of a Plinian eruption (VEI 5).
Pyroclastic flows are unstoppable and are characterized by the remarkably destructive dynamism of incandescent, avalanche like masses rushing down the mountain due to the collapse of the eruptive column. The higher the column rises, the greater the potential energy it will have to dissipate. The heat inherent in this superheated avalanche would instantly vaporize any human being due to the extreme temperatures of the surging particulate matter. Because of this excessive heat, personal protective equipment in the Red Zone, such as gas masks, which would melt along with the very body they are meant to protect, is completely unfeasible. The same applies to collective sheltering inside buildings or bunkers not specifically designed and tested to withstand such extreme conditions. In this regard, it is worth noting that although the Ospedale del Mare (located in the Red Zone in Naples, Ponticelli) features massive antiseismic construction, like all other existing structures in the Red Zone, it offers no protection against pyroclastic flows; therefore, its placement in that location is a design flaw.
The areas where danger is highest and survival cannot be guaranteed in the event of an eruption are called Red Zones. Mount Vesuvius has two Red Zones: Red Zone 1 (R1) and Red Zone 2 (R2). Red Zone 1 is the area exposed to invasion by deadly pyroclastic flows. In Red Zone 2, on the other hand, which statistically extends eastward, heavy fallout of ash and lapilli is to be expected, which would make breathing extremely difficult, traffic impossible, and visibility reduced to just a few meters. Flat roofs could collapse under the overload of accumulated ash and lapilli, bringing down the underlying floors with them.
Regarding pyroclastic fallout, two things must be noted: first, this phenomenon is inherent in every type of eruption at Vesuvius. The second element, which requires proper operational emphasis, is tied to the timing of these lethal phenomena. Ash and lapilli fallout coincides with the very onset of the eruptive event, whereas pyroclastic flows occur slightly later, though they are far more destructive. This explains why, in both Red Zone 1 and Red Zone 2, preventive evacuation is absolutely essential in the event of an eruption warning.
Outside the Red Zone lies the Yellow Zone, which extends predominantly and statistically eastward. Here, moderate to severe disruptions are expected, especially affecting territories located downwind of Vesuvius and aligned with the prevailing winds; in the Yellow Zone, targeted evacuations cannot be ruled out. However, since this involves windborne fallout material, any assessment of extreme hazard or disruption will have to be made while the eruption is already underway.
Within the Yellow Zone, to the north of Vesuvius, there is also an overlapping Blue Zone, where intense flooding and torrents of mud (lahars) are possible during an eruption, flowing down from the volcano along natural drainage lines toward the Nola basin (conca nolana). Due to heavy surface runoff caused by water expelled from the volcano, stream culverts would blow out and water would accumulate at stream confluences, reaching depths of up to about three meters.
The safety issues weighing on the Vesuvian area are primarily linked to the predictive uncertainty of both the volcanic eruption itself and its eruptive intensity. Ideally, a forecast should be formulated at least three days before the onset of violent eruptive activity, with timing that avoids false alarms or missed alarms as much as possible. Regarding the prediction of the eruptive style, Civil Protection authorities, on a statistical basis, have decided to adopt a medium scale Subplinian event (VEI 4) as the reference eruption for emergency plans, rather than the maximum known event (VEI 5). This decision, endorsed by the Major Risks Commission (Commissione Grandi Rischi), carries immense responsibility, even more so when the leadership of the Vesuvius Observatory (Osservatorio Vesuviano) reiterates that the passing of decades and centuries does not warrant a reassessment of eruptive intensity, which would supposedly remain unchanged (at VEI 4) over time, at least until new scientific discoveries overturn this optimistic outlook. Should these statements fail to rest on rock solid scientific foundations, which, in any case, clash with current specialized literature, a warning scenario could statistically result in a successful evacuation accompanied by a volcanic catastrophe.
Mount Vesuvius: Highlight of the Different Hazard Zones

                                                                                      Vincenzo Savarese






Nessun commento:

Posta un commento

I commenti sono moderati dall'autore prima della pubblicazione. Non sono ammessi link pubblicitari o esterni.